COMFEE' or EdgeStar? Dishwashers Compared in 2026
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
This comfee vs EdgeStar dishwasher comparison looks at two distinct approaches to clean dishes. Both units offer six wash cycles, but they serve different needs. The COMFEE' model is a portable countertop appliance with a built-in water tank, ideal for spaces without plumbing. The EdgeStar is a built-in unit designed for permanent installation. You need to decide between flexible placement and higher capacity.
Key differences
| Aspect | COMFEE' Minilite Compact Dishwasher with Water Tank | EdgeStar 18-Inch Built-In Dishwasher |
|---|---|---|
| Installation Type | Countertop | Built-In |
| Width | 16.5 inches | 18 inches |
| Capacity | 30+ items | 8 place settings |
| Target Space | Apartments, RVs | not listed |
| Features | Water Tank | Leakage sensor |
Which one should you choose?
Choose COMFEE' Minilite Compact Dishwasher with Water Tank if
- You need a portable unit that does not require plumbing hookup.
- You are placing the dishwasher in an RV or small apartment.
- You want a compact footprint under 17 inches wide.
Choose EdgeStar 18-Inch Built-In Dishwasher if
- You are replacing a trash compactor or similar built-in appliance.
- You prefer a permanent installation with a leakage sensor.
- You want a stainless steel finish for your kitchen.
Verdict: Choose the COMFEE' if you lack plumbing access or need a portable solution for travel. Pick the EdgeStar if you have a dedicated built-in space and want a permanent fixture with a leak protection sensor. Both provide six wash cycles to handle daily cleaning tasks.
COMFEE vs EdgeStar Key Differences
installation type
The COMFEE' Minilite is a countertop appliance designed for flexibility. You can place it anywhere on a counter without plumbing connections, thanks to its 1.32-gallon built-in water tank. It also supports faucet hookups. The EdgeStar model is strictly a built-in unit. It requires permanent installation into cabinetry, such as replacing a trash compactor. This makes the COMFEE' better for renters or RVs, while the EdgeStar suits fixed kitchen layouts.
width
Width matters for fitting your space. The COMFEE' unit measures 16.5 inches wide. The EdgeStar model is listed as 18 inches wide in its key specs, though its physical depth is 22.4 inches and width is listed as 17.6 inches in other specs. The EdgeStar is marketed as an 18-inch wide unit for standard cutouts. The COMFEE' is slightly narrower, which may help in tighter countertop spaces.
capacity
Capacity differs significantly between these two. The EdgeStar dishwasher holds eight place settings, which is standard for a built-in unit. It includes a silverware basket and cup tray. The COMFEE' portable model washes over 30 items, including plates up to 9.5 inches. While the COMFEE' lists item count, the EdgeStar uses place settings. For larger families or entertaining, the EdgeStar offers more structured capacity.
target space
These units target different environments. The COMFEE' is built for apartments, RVs, dorms, and boats where plumbing is unavailable or restricted. Its portable nature allows you to move it or store it away. The EdgeStar is designed for residential kitchens with permanent plumbing access. It replaces older appliances like trash compactors. Choose the COMFEE' for mobility and temporary housing, and the EdgeStar for a permanent kitchen upgrade.
features
Feature sets highlight their distinct uses. The COMFEE' includes an Air Refresh mode to circulate air and keep dishes dry and odor-free. It also features a high-temperature Hygiene cycle reaching 162°F. The EdgeStar focuses on protection and efficiency with a leakage sensor that shuts off water flow during leaks. It offers Sanitize and Hi Temp options. The COMFEE' offers unique drying flexibility, while the EdgeStar adds leak protection.
wash cycles
Both dishwashers provide six wash cycles. The COMFEE' offers Normal, Rapid, Hygiene, Fruit, Glass, and an Air Refresh drying mode. The EdgeStar provides Heavy, Normal, ECO, Glass, Rapid, and Rinse cycles, with three additional options like Sanitize and Heated Dry. Both cover basic cleaning needs. The COMFEE' includes a Fruit program, while the EdgeStar includes an ECO cycle. The variety is comparable for daily use.
Which comfee or edgestar suits you
Renter in a small apartment without plumbing
The COMFEE' model features a built-in 1.32-gallon water tank. You can place it anywhere on your counter without connecting to tap water. This portable design fits RVs and dorms perfectly. It washes up to 30 items, including 9.5-inch plates, making it a practical choice for tight spaces.
Homeowner replacing a trash compactor
The EdgeStar BIDW1802SS is a built-in unit measuring 17.75 inches wide. It replaces older appliances like trash compactors easily. With a leakage sensor that shuts off water flow, it protects your home from damage. The 52dB operation ensures quiet performance during your daily routine.
User needing sanitization for baby dishes
The COMFEE' hygiene cycle heats water to 162℉. This high temperature makes it safe for cleaning little ones' dinnerware. The air refresh mode also circulates air to keep the machine dry and fresh. You can turn this mode off if you do not need it.
The products compared
COMFEE' Minilite Compact Dishwasher with Water Tank
Best for: Small spaces and portable use
- Installation Type
- Countertop, Portable
- Width
- 16.5 inches
- Wash Cycles
- 6
- Target Space
- Apartments, RVs, Dorms
- Features
- Water Tank
- Color
- Black
View on Amazon: COMFEE' Minilite Compact Dishwasher with Water Tank Affiliate link
This COMFEE' countertop unit measures 16.5 inches wide and 17.2 inches high. It holds a 1.32-gallon built-in water tank for manual filling or connects to a faucet. You get six wash programs, including a high-temperature hygiene cycle that reaches 162℉. The compact design fits small spaces like apartments or RVs. It weighs 36.6 pounds and offers an air refresh drying mode.
Pros
- Compact 16.5-inch width fits tight countertops
- Built-in 1.32-gallon tank for no-plumbing use
- Six wash programs including high-temp hygiene
- Air refresh mode reduces moisture and odors
Cons
- Small capacity suits only light loads
- Requires manual water filling without hookup
- Limited to countertop installation only
Good fit if
- You live in an apartment with limited space
- You need a dishwasher for an RV or camper
- You want to avoid permanent plumbing connections
Skip if
- You need to wash more than 30 items at once
- You require a built-in installation under a counter
- You prefer automatic water filling without manual effort
Verdict: COMFEE' Countertop Mini Dishwasher suits renters and RV owners who need a compact, portable cleaning solution. It fits users who value flexibility over high capacity.
EdgeStar 18-Inch Built-In Dishwasher
Best for: narrow kitchens and appliance replacement
- Installation Type
- Built-In
- Width
- 18 in
- Capacity
- 8 place settings
- Noise Level
- 52 dB
- Wash Cycles
- 6 cycles
- Color
- Stainless Steel
View on Amazon: EdgeStar 18-Inch Built-In Dishwasher Affiliate link
This EdgeStar model is an 18-inch built-in dishwasher designed for tight spaces. It holds eight place settings and runs at 52 dB. The unit includes six wash cycles and three options like sanitize and heated dry. A leakage sensor protects against water damage. It fits standard 32.5-inch height cutouts. This unit suits those replacing older appliances or needing a slim footprint.
Pros
- Holds up to eight place settings
- Six wash cycles including Heavy and Rapid
- 52 dB noise level for quiet operation
- Leakage sensor shuts off water flow automatically
- Stainless steel interior and exterior finish
Cons
- Narrow 18-inch width limits capacity
- Built-in installation requires cabinetry modification
- No smart features or app control listed
Good fit if
- You need a slim 18-inch unit for tight spaces
- You want a built-in dishwasher with a leakage sensor
- You are replacing a trash compactor or old appliance
Skip if
- You require a portable or countertop model
- You need a wider 24-inch capacity for large loads
- You want a dishwasher with smart home integration
Verdict: EdgeStar 18 Inch Built-In Dishwasher fits buyers with narrow kitchen layouts who need reliable built-in performance. It offers essential cycles and safety features for small households.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | COMFEE' Minilite Compact Dishwasher with Water Tank | EdgeStar 18-Inch Built-In Dishwasher |
|---|---|---|
| Installation Type | Countertop, Portable | Built-In |
| Width | 16.5 inches | 18 in |
| Capacity | not stated | 8 place settings |
| Noise Level | not stated | 52 dB |
| Wash Cycles | 6 | 6 cycles |
| Target Space | Apartments, RVs, Dorms | not stated |
| Features | Water Tank | not stated |
| Color | Black | Stainless Steel |
| Dimensions | 17.1 × 16.5 × 17.2 inches | 17.6 × 22.4 × 32.5 inches |
| Weight | 36.6 pounds | 62.8 pounds |
| Size | Minilite | not stated |
| Model | CDC17P0ABB | BIDW1802SS |
Frequently asked questions
Which dishwasher is better for a small apartment without plumbing?
The COMFEE' Minilite is the better choice for renters without plumbing access. It features a built-in water tank that holds 1.32 gallons. This allows you to place it anywhere on a counter. You do not need to connect it to tap water. The EdgeStar model requires built-in installation and plumbing connections.
What are the physical dimensions of the COMFEE' compact dishwasher?
The COMFEE' Minilite measures 16.5 inches in width, 17.2 inches in height, and 17.1 inches in length. It weighs 36.6 pounds. These compact dimensions make it suitable for tight counter spaces. The EdgeStar unit is larger, measuring 22.4 inches wide and 32.5 inches tall.
How many wash cycles does the EdgeStar built-in dishwasher offer?
The EdgeStar 18-Inch Built-In Dishwasher offers six wash cycles. This matches the cycle count of the COMFEE' model. Both units provide essential cleaning options for daily use. The EdgeStar model focuses on built-in performance for narrow kitchens.
Is the EdgeStar dishwasher suitable for RV use?
The EdgeStar dishwasher is not ideal for RVs. It is a built-in unit designed for narrow kitchen layouts. It requires permanent installation and plumbing. The COMFEE' model is better for RVs because it is portable. It fits users who value flexibility and do not need high capacity.
What color options are available for these dishwashers?
The COMFEE' Minilite is available in Black. The EdgeStar 18-Inch Built-In Dishwasher comes in Stainless Steel. These are the only color options listed for each model. The COMFEE' unit is designed for countertop placement, while the EdgeStar is for built-in installation.
Does the COMFEE' dishwasher include a water tank?
Yes, the COMFEE' Minilite includes a built-in water tank. This tank holds 1.32 gallons of water. It allows the unit to operate without a direct water line connection. You can also hook it up to a faucet if preferred. The EdgeStar model does not have this feature.
Which dishwasher has a higher weight capacity?
The EdgeStar dishwasher is heavier than the COMFEE' model. The EdgeStar unit weighs 62.8 pounds. The COMFEE' Minilite weighs 36.6 pounds. The higher weight of the EdgeStar reflects its built-in construction. The COMFEE' is lighter due to its portable countertop design.