Dual Compartment vs Single Compartment Trash Cans: Which Should You Buy?
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
Choosing between a dual compartment vs single compartment trash can depends on your waste habits. Both the Amazon Basics and Kraus models use stainless steel and offer hands-free operation to keep your kitchen hygienic. The main difference lies in separation: one splits waste into two bins, while the other provides a single large space. You also need to decide between motion sensor activation and a foot pedal. These specs determine how the can fits your routine and space.
Key differences
| Aspect | Amazon Basics 80L Dual Touchless Can | Kraus WasteGuard 13.2-Gallon Step Trash Can |
|---|---|---|
| Compartment Count | Dual Compartment | Single Compartment |
| Capacity | 80 L | 50 L |
| Opening Mechanism | Motion Sensor | Foot pedal |
| Width | 14.4 inches | 14.9 inches |
| Height | 26.8 inches | 25.1 inches |
| Weight | 9.83 pounds | 14.6 pounds |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Amazon Basics 80L Dual Touchless Can if
- You need to separate recycling from general waste without buying two separate cans.
- You prefer a larger total capacity of 80 liters for busy households.
- You want a lighter unit that is easier to move or clean underneath.
Choose Kraus WasteGuard 13.2-Gallon Step Trash Can if
- You prefer a manual foot pedal over electronic sensors for reliability.
- You have a smaller kitchen space and need a narrower footprint.
- You want a soft-close lid to reduce noise and protect nearby cabinets.
Verdict: The Amazon Basics model suits those who need to sort waste and want a larger, touchless solution. The Kraus option is better for smaller spaces where a quiet, manual pedal operation is preferred. Your choice depends on whether you prioritize waste separation or mechanical simplicity.
Dual vs Single Compartment Trash Cans
Compartment Count
The Amazon Basics model features a dual compartment design with an 80-liter capacity, allowing you to separate recyclables from general waste efficiently. This split layout is ideal for busy households needing ample space for distinct waste streams. In contrast, the Kraus WasteGuard is a single compartment unit with a 50-liter capacity. It offers one large space for all trash, which simplifies bin management but prevents on-site sorting. If you prioritize recycling separation, the dual setup provides clear advantages. If you prefer simplicity and fewer bins to manage, the single compartment is more straightforward. The choice depends on your waste sorting habits.
Capacity
Capacity is a major differentiator between these two units. The Amazon Basics trash can holds 80 liters, which is significantly larger than the Kraus model. This extra volume means you can go longer between taking out the trash, making it suitable for families or high-traffic kitchens. The Kraus WasteGuard offers 13.2 gallons, or 50 liters. While still functional, this smaller size requires more frequent emptying, especially if you are using the dual compartments of the other unit. If you generate a lot of waste or want to minimize trips to the curb, the larger 80-liter bin is the practical choice. For smaller households with less waste, the 50-liter size may suffice.
Opening Mechanism
Both units offer hands-free operation, but they use different technologies. The Amazon Basics model uses a motion sensor for automatic opening. It features innovative delay technology that minimizes unnecessary openings to extend battery life. You simply wave your hand to open the lid. The Kraus WasteGuard uses a step pedal mechanism. You press the foot pedal with your toe to open the lid. This mechanical approach does not rely on batteries for the opening action. Some users prefer the convenience of touchless sensors, while others trust the reliability of a foot pedal. The sensor offers zero contact, while the pedal keeps your hands away from the lid.
Lid Features
The lid designs differ in functionality and closure. The Amazon Basics lid focuses on odor control and security. It locks in odors effectively and includes an open/close button for manual override when needed. The Kraus WasteGuard lid features a soft-close mechanism. This internal hinge system ensures the lid closes smoothly and quietly, preventing it from slamming or hitting walls. It also helps protect against scuffs on nearby cabinetry. The soft-close feature adds a layer of convenience and noise reduction that the standard lockable lid of the Amazon Basics model does not explicitly offer. If quiet operation and gentle closure are priorities, the Kraus design has the edge.
Dimensions
Physical size affects where you can place these cans. The Amazon Basics unit measures 18.5 inches in length, 14.4 inches in width, and 26.8 inches in height. It weighs 9.83 pounds. The Kraus WasteGuard is slightly shorter at 25.1 inches in height and narrower in width at 14.9 inches, with a length of 18 inches. It is heavier at 14.6 pounds. The Amazon Basics model is taller, which might be an issue for under-counter storage in some kitchens. The Kraus model is more compact vertically. The width difference is minimal, so both should fit in similar cabinet spaces. Consider your available vertical clearance when choosing between the 26.8-inch and 25.1-inch heights.
Which trash can fits your kitchen
You need large volume waste separation
The Amazon Basics model offers an 80-liter dual compartment capacity. This large size allows you to separate recyclables and general waste efficiently. The motion sensor opening provides hands-free operation, while the fingerprint-resistant finish keeps the stainless steel surface looking clean with minimal effort. It is ideal for busy households.
You prefer quiet soft-close lids
The Kraus WasteGuard features a soft-close lid mechanism that prevents slamming. This quiet operation protects walls and objects from scuffs. The foot pedal allows hands-free disposal without touching the lid. The removable bucket simplifies cleaning, and the durable stainless steel construction resists corrosion for long-term kitchen use.
You want extended battery life
Amazon Basics uses innovative delay motion sensor technology to minimize unnecessary openings. This feature extends battery life for efficient, long-lasting operation. The secure lid locks in odors effectively. You can still open it manually using the dedicated button when needed, combining automation with reliable manual control for your kitchen waste.
Quick picks
| # | Product | Best for | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Amazon Basics 80L Dual Touchless Can | Large kitchens needing waste separation | Check price of Amazon Basics 80L Dual Touchless Can on Amazon |
| 2 | Kraus WasteGuard 13.2-Gallon Step Trash Can | Single-bin kitchen waste with pedal access | Check price of Kraus WasteGuard 13.2-Gallon Step Trash Can on Amazon |
The products compared
Amazon Basics 80L Dual Touchless Can
Best for: Large kitchens needing waste separation
- Compartment Count
- Dual Compartment (what this guide is about)
- Capacity
- 80 L
- Opening Mechanism
- Motion Sensor
- Primary Material
- Stainless Steel
- Power Source
- Battery
- Features
- Fingerprint Resistant, Odor Control
View on Amazon: Amazon Basics 80L Dual Touchless Can Affiliate link
This Amazon Basics unit offers an 80-liter dual compartment design for waste separation. It uses a motion sensor opening mechanism and runs on battery power. The stainless steel body resists fingerprints and includes an odor control lid. Its dimensions are 14.4 by 18.5 by 26.8 inches. It suits busy households needing ample space and hands-free operation.
Pros
- 80-liter dual compartment capacity
- Motion sensor opening mechanism
- Fingerprint-resistant stainless steel finish
- Odor control lid with open/close button
Cons
- Battery power source requires replacements
- Heavy at 9.83 pounds
- Larger footprint than single-compartment models
Good fit if
- You need to separate recyclables from waste
- You want hands-free operation for hygiene
- You have space for a large bin
Skip if
- You prefer plug-in power over batteries
- You have limited kitchen floor space
- You only need a single waste bin
Verdict: Amazon Basics 80L Dual Sensor Trash Can fits households that prioritize waste separation and large capacity. It is a practical choice for those who value hands-free convenience and a fingerprint-resistant finish.
Kraus WasteGuard 13.2-Gallon Step Trash Can
Best for: Single-bin kitchen waste with pedal access
- Compartment Count
- Single Compartment (what this guide is about)
- Capacity
- 13.2 Gallon / 50 L
- Opening Mechanism
- Foot pedal
- Primary Material
- Stainless steel
- Soft Close
- Soft close lid
- Target Space
- Kitchen
View on Amazon: Kraus WasteGuard 13.2-Gallon Step Trash Can Affiliate link
This single-compartment trash can holds 13.2 gallons and measures 18 x 14.9 x 25.1 inches. It uses a foot pedal for hands-free operation and features a soft-close lid. The spot-free stainless steel body resists corrosion and fingerprints. The removable bucket and bag securing system simplify cleaning. It fits standard bags and tight spaces.
Pros
- 13.2 gallon capacity fits standard bags
- Soft-close lid reduces noise and scuffs
- Foot pedal allows hands-free use
- Removable bucket aids cleaning
- Spot-free stainless steel resists fingerprints
Cons
- Single compartment limits sorting options
- 14.6 pounds weight adds bulk
- Foot pedal requires floor clearance
Good fit if
- You need a single bin for general waste
- You prefer hands-free pedal operation
- You want a slim rectangular profile
Skip if
- You require dual compartments for recycling
- You need a motion sensor activation
- You prefer a smaller 10 gallon size
Verdict: Kraus WasteGuard 13.2 Gal Step Pedal suits users who want a durable, single-bin solution with a soft-close lid and pedal mechanism. It is not ideal for those needing recycling separation or sensor activation.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Amazon Basics 80L Dual Touchless Can | Kraus WasteGuard 13.2-Gallon Step Trash Can |
|---|---|---|
| Capacity | 80 L | 13.2 Gallon / 50 L |
| Opening Mechanism | Motion Sensor | Foot pedal |
| Compartment Count | Dual Compartment | Single Compartment |
| Primary Material | Stainless Steel | Stainless steel |
| Soft Close | not stated | Soft close lid |
| Power Source | Battery | not stated |
| Target Space | not stated | Kitchen |
| Features | Fingerprint Resistant, Odor Control | Soft-Close, Step Pedal, Inner Bucket |
| Control Type | Touchless | not stated |
| Color | Stainless Steel | Spot Free Stainless |
| Dimensions | 18.5 × 14.4 × 26.8 inches | 18 × 14.9 × 25.1 inches |
| Weight | 9.83 pounds | 14.6 pounds |
| Size | 80L | Single Compartment 13.2 Gallon |
| Model | AB-80-4R | KTCP-100SFS |
Frequently asked questions
Is a dual compartment trash can worth the extra space?
Yes, if you need to separate recycling from general waste without using multiple bins. The Amazon Basics 80L model offers a dual compartment layout with an 80-liter capacity. This large size allows you to keep distinct waste streams organized in a single footprint, which is practical for busy households.
Which trash can is better for small kitchens?
A single compartment bin is often better for tight spaces. The Kraus WasteGuard measures 14.9 inches wide and 25.1 inches high. Its single-bin design fits easily into narrower cabinets or corners. You save counter space by avoiding the wider footprint required for dual-compartment units like the 18.5-inch Amazon Basics model.
Do I need a touchless lid for waste separation?
It depends on your hygiene priorities. The Amazon Basics dual unit includes a touchless sensor for hands-free operation. This feature helps keep your hands clean when handling separate waste streams. Single-bin options like the Kraus model use a step pedal instead, which also offers hands-free access without electronic sensors.
Can I recycle effectively with a single trash can?
You can recycle, but you must separate items manually before disposal. A single compartment bin like the Kraus WasteGuard holds 13.2 gallons in one space. You will need to rinse or sort recyclables into other containers. Dual units allow you to toss items directly into the correct bin simultaneously.
How much weight can a stainless steel trash can hold?
Capacity varies by model and construction. The Amazon Basics dual unit weighs 9.83 pounds empty and holds 80 liters. The Kraus single compartment model weighs 14.6 pounds. Heavier construction often indicates more durable steel. Check the weight spec to gauge sturdiness, as a heavier bin may resist tipping when full.
Is fingerprint resistant finish important for kitchen bins?
It helps maintain a clean appearance with less frequent wiping. The Amazon Basics 80L dual bin features a fingerprint-resistant stainless steel finish. This coating reduces visible smudges from daily use. The Kraus model uses spot-free stainless steel, which also resists marks. Both finishes help the can look cleaner between cleanings.
What is the difference between sensor and pedal operation?
Sensors use motion detection to open the lid automatically. Pedals use a mechanical lever under the foot. The Amazon Basics dual bin uses a touchless sensor for automatic opening. The Kraus single bin uses a step pedal. Sensors offer a more modern experience, while pedals are purely mechanical and require no batteries.